Amish Chicken and Noodles for #SundaySupper

Homestyle chicken with noodles is a true comfort food.
Amish Chicken and Noodles

Amish Chicken and Noodles

By Sue Lau | Palatable Pastime

I  am very pleased to be able to host the Sunday Supper event for this week which is Regional Specialties. I know everyone has a special food from the area where they live which they can be proud of. For me, having moved around a bit with my husband and daughter due to the military, we feel right at home with many regional foods.

Since we currently live in Cincinnati, I thought of doing some of the foods from here, the obvious of which are mostly Cincinnati chili and goetta. In fact, the first post I ever did for Sunday Supper (last year) was for Cincinnati Chili as part of the “Hometown Favorites” event. I was happy to share that one as I have a pretty good recipe for it. If you haven’t had that chili before, it is a Greek style, and never meant to really be compared with a Texas chili at all. They are two different animals completely.  In Cincinnati, we  like  to serve it 5-Way, which means chili on top of spaghetti, with beans, onions, and a terrific mound of finely shredded cheese. It is usually served with oyster crackers and a bottle of Louisiana hot sauce.

I like Goetta too, and if you haven’t had that one, it is a mixture of pork with pinhead oats which is made into a loaf, then sliced and cooked in the skillet until it gets a bit crisp. It needs to be crisp to have that properly. And that is an option instead of breakfast sausage, but by no means does it stop there. I’ve seen it in lots of things- biscuit gravy, tacos, as hot dogs (a local company even packages it that way in casings) and so many more. The flavor is similar to pork sausage, but then again, not. I thought about sharing a recipe for it, but I have some things with goetta on the blog already, and didn’t have chicken noodles,  so went with that instead. Sometimes, it’s just about balance. I’ll get to making goetta some other time.

As for the Amish chicken and noodles, that is not entirely a “Cincinnati” recipe, but one for Ohio in general. There is a huge Amish community up towards Millersburg  and Sugarcreek in the NE part of the state, but there are quite a few Amish in the SW Ohio area, particularly around Lebanon. You won’t see them around much (even though there are road signs with the horse and cart here and there) as they generally keep to themselves, and who can blame them?  Also I know Bob Evans (the restaurant) runs out of southern Ohio, and one of their staples is chicken and noodles, but I find it to be a bit disappointing as it is kind of soupy. (It gets better if it sits refrigerated overnight) so you will find my recipe to be unlike theirs.

I know a lot of traditional recipes for this and dumplings tend to toss a chicken in a pot, boil the bejeezus out of it to get their stock then pull the chicken from the bones and throw the bones away, which I find quite disturbing. One, the chicken after that much boiling will have no flavor. Two, if you want chicken stock, don’t toss the bones- save them in the freezer and when you have a good amount, boil *those* down with a few aromatics to get your stock for next time.

In this recipe, I would sometimes roast my own chicken and make my noodles from scratch- and I was going to do that but ended up misplacing my recipe somewhere. (It happens) so I decided to do a  quick and dirty which is great for busy nights. I essentially bought a ready-to-go rotisserie chicken and pulled the meat off, tossed the skin (and saved those bones!) and instead of noodles from scratch, used a bag of dried noodles off the shelf. Doing this saves a lot of time and I know that for many people, saving time is really important! And for those of you who like things from scratch, the other recipe will turn up and I’ll post it later.

But I do hope you enjoy this recipe, and make sure to check out the huge list of recipes from Sunday Supper which follows the recipe printout. There are a lot of great sounding recipes in there. I can’t wait to try them! I pin my favorites to Pinterest to save for later.

And thanks for joining us for this event!


Amish Chicken and Noodles for #SundaySupper

Amish Chicken and Noodles

  • Servings: 6-8
  • Difficulty: moderate
  • Print

Amish Chicken and Noodles


  • 1-1/2 pounds chopped cooked (roasted) chicken
  • 1 cup chopped onion
  • 1 cup chopped carrot
  • 1 cup chopped celery
  • 2 cloves garlic, chopped
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground turmeric
  • 1 tablespoon minced fresh sage
  • 1 tablespoon minced fresh rosemary
  • 1 tablespoon minced fresh thyme
  • 1 tablespoon minced Italian parsley
  • 3 cups chicken broth
  • 1 cup whole milk
  • 1/4 cup all purpose flour
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • 16 ounces dry Amish style egg noodles or kluski noodles


  1. Chop chicken and vegetables and set aside.
  2. Heat salted water for noodles and cook according to package directions, timing it so they get done about the same time as the sauce. Mine cook in 25 minutes, but some brands cook in far less- so take what your package states into consideration.
  3. Heat oil in a deep pan and saute the onions, carrots, celery and garlic until soft.
  4. Stir in the salt, pepper, turmeric and herbs.
  5. Sprinkle the flour over the vegetables and cook for a minute, stirring to evenly coat, then add the butter, chicken broth and milk.
  6. Continue cooking and stirring over low heat until mixture begins to thicken, then add in the chicken and stir again.
  7. When the chicken sauce is hot, combine it with the hot cooked egg noodles.

From the kitchen of

Sunday Supper Regional Specialties

Hosted by Sue Lau of Palatable Pastime






Side Dishes:


Main Dish:


Plus Rhubarb Steamed Pudding and Favorite Regional Recipes from Sunday Supper Movement

Sunday Supper MovementJoin the #SundaySupper conversation on twitter on Sunday! We tweet throughout the day and share recipes from all over the world. Our weekly chat starts at 7:00 pm ET. Follow the #SundaySupper hashtag and remember to include it in your tweets to join in the chat. To get more great Sunday Supper Recipes, visit our website or check out our Pinterest board.

Would you like to join the Sunday Supper Movement? It’s easy. You can sign up by clicking here: Sunday Supper Movement

You might also like:

Country Style Green Beans with Ham

Buttermilk Biscuits

Amish Hot Bacon Slaw

Can’t Find a Recipe? | Help
Recipe Index A-M | Recipe Index N-Z | Home


48 responses

  1. My grandma grew up in Amish country, and we ate a lot of chicken and noodles when I was growing up. It’s still one of my favorites. 🙂 It’s funny you mention goetta–Before I decided to make something South Dakotan, I was toying with the idea of making something with goetta, since I’ve done Cincinnati chili to death on my blog.

    • Thanks! I thought maybe the next goetta recipe I did would be for the actual goetta since some don’t have it. But I didn’t have time so held off. Maybe next month sometime.

  2. I love Amish food. We have a large Amish community in Lancaster, about a hour or so from us. This looks so tasty. Thanks for hosting.

  3. I wasn’t able to make it to this week’s SS theme, but oh so love that you shared a Midwestern “Amish” recipe! I grew up in the Midwest (Iowa) and have delicious memories of their food. Whenever I return home to Iowa, my husband and I always seek out an Amish restaurant for food such as this. Thank you for sharing this delicious recipe!!!!

  4. Amish food is pure comfort food for me! We love to dine at Hartville Kitchen where Amish recipes and cooking take center stage! These chicken and noodles would fit right in! (and I agree with you on the soupy Bob Evans ones, but hubby loves them! ha)

  5. I love this! I’m from WV and this brings back memories…an Amish couple would travel through our neighborhood each week and sell different things. There was nothing like a jar of chicken and noodles. We would fight over it…I think this is what we’re having for dinner tonight!

  6. I grew up in the middle of Kansas with an Amish settlement very near. Everytime I go back I buy some Amish noodles. My mom made a killer Chicken and Noodles dish. Much different than this. And she made her own noodles. I need to blog about it. It’s such good stuff.

    • You should! I’ve seen a few variations on this theme. Of course, the homemade noodles are better and I have a recipe for those (somewhere) but misplace it before getting it posted. And since I have photos of those in two separate unposted recipes, I don’t want to redevelop the noodle recipe since it will show up an hour after I post a new one. And no sense in posting two almost identical noodle recipes. Don’t want to waste those other photos. So the packaged noodles works, especially for people who don’t want to make the dough, etc. You can still use homemade noodles in this. Even square dumplings.

  7. Nice comfort food! I like this quick version mainly because I’ve never made my own pasta. One day I’ll tackle it.

  8. We never did venture into Amish Country when we were in the Dayton area, probably should have. But this noodle dish looks fantastic; pinned!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: